The recording doesn’t lie.

CAST

Ed Herbstman
Tami Sagher
Libby George
Christian Paluck

BEN
ERICA
MOM
BARTENDER

Produced by Jonathan Mitchell
Written by Jonathan Mitchell, Ed Herbstman, and Melanie Hoopes
Special thanks: Ira Glass, Peter Clowney, Kerrie Hillman, Lisa Pollack, Jonathan Menjivar, and Chris Bannon
Recorded at WNYC, Magnet Theater, and on location in New York City

Originally produced for This American Life